Fairplay isn't just a mountain town with great views — it's officially recognized as the Trout Fishing Capital of Colorado. The South Park basin is surrounded by over 50 miles of Gold Medal trout streams, world-class reservoirs, and public water access that most anglers never discover because they're too busy fighting for a spot on the Frying Pan or the Blue.
Staying at Skyfall Chalet puts you in the middle of all of it. The closest fishable water is 20 minutes away. The Arkansas River — one of the most famous trout rivers in the country — is about 40 minutes south. And if you're into stillwater fishing, the reservoirs produce trophy-class trout year-round, including through the ice.
Rivers & Streams
Middle Fork of the South Platte River
This river runs right through Fairplay and is accessible from town. Quintessential high-elevation meadow stream fishing — long, slow runs through open grassland with mountain views in every direction. Fishes well with nymphs and dry-dropper rigs. Public access is good in town, though private ranches hold some of the best stretches — a local guide can get you on that water.
South Platte River — Hartsel Area
South of Fairplay toward Hartsel, the South Platte meanders through wide-open South Park basin. It feels like you're fishing in Montana. More technical water that rewards patience and a careful approach. Less pressure than the Middle Fork and a local favorite for wade fishing.
Arkansas River
Heading south on 285 toward Buena Vista and Salida puts you on one of the most celebrated trout rivers in the American West. The stretch through Browns Canyon is particularly productive, with a mix of pocket water, riffles, and deep runs. You could combine a morning of fishing with an afternoon float. Guided trips available from outfitters in Buena Vista and Salida.
Rough & Tumbling Creek
A quieter option for anglers who prefer smaller water. Classic mountain stream with pocket water, small pools, and native brook trout. Won't produce trophy fish, but the setting is beautiful and you'll almost certainly have it to yourself.
Reservoirs & Lakes
South Park's reservoirs are some of the most productive stillwater fisheries in Colorado. They're especially popular for ice fishing in winter, and several produce fish over 20 inches regularly.
Antero Reservoir
Sitting at over 9,000 feet with sweeping views of the Collegiate Peaks, Antero is known for producing large trout — fish over 20 inches are not uncommon. Fishes well from shore or by float tube. In winter, it's one of the top ice fishing destinations in Colorado.
Spinney Mountain Reservoir
Where you go for big fish. Managed as a trophy fishery with special regulations (artificial flies and lures only). Consistently produces rainbow and brown trout in the 18–24 inch range, with pike as a bonus. Popular and earns its reputation.
Eleven Mile Reservoir
The biggest reservoir in the area and the most diverse fishery. Trout, kokanee salmon, pike, and even carp. The surrounding canyon is gorgeous — combine a fishing trip with camping, kayaking, or exploring. The canyon below the dam has excellent stream fishing too.
Tarryall Reservoir
Often overlooked in favor of Spinney and Eleven Mile, Tarryall is a solid option with less pressure. Scenic drive northeast through the Tarryall Valley. Good shore access and the creek below the reservoir is worth fishing too.
Seasonal Fishing Guide
Spring (April – May)
Ice-off on the reservoirs is one of the most productive times of year — trout are hungry and feeding aggressively near the surface. Rivers can be high from runoff, so stillwater is often the better bet. Late May is prime time for the "Mother's Day Caddis" hatch on the Arkansas.
Summer (June – September)
Peak season for river fishing. Hatches are consistent, water levels stabilize, and long evenings make for great dry fly fishing. Reservoirs fish well early and late in the day. Best time to book a guided trip on the Arkansas.
Fall (September – November)
Brown trout spawning season means aggressive fish on the streams. Many locals' favorite time — fewer people, cooler weather, and fish that are actively feeding before winter. Gold aspens along the streams make for an unforgettable backdrop.
Winter (December – March)
Ice fishing takes over. Antero, Spinney, Eleven Mile, and Jefferson Lake all have strong ice fishing scenes. Sitting on the ice at 9,000+ feet with mountains all around is a uniquely Colorado experience. The Middle Fork stays fishable in winter for the hardy — midges are the go-to pattern.
Licenses & Local Outfitters
You'll need a valid Colorado fishing license, available online through Colorado Parks & Wildlife or at local shops. For guided trips, Breckenridge-based outfitters like Mountain Angler and Breckenridge Outfitters cover the South Park area. In Fairplay, South Park Anglers is a solid resource. For the Arkansas River, Salida and Buena Vista have multiple guide services.
Cast a Line from Your Mountain Basecamp
Skyfall Chalet is 20–40 minutes from every fishing spot in this guide. Come home to the hot tub and sauna after a day on the water.
Check Availability — Book Direct & Save